Im surely going to love this. AWESOME. YES KW! Step 1: In a medium-sized pan, add in your chicken and take two forks and shred the chunks of chicken. And if you try a new filler ingredient- let us know which one. Learning to do it from scratch is insurance that Ill never lose my favorite chicken sandwich. Deanna- yes it does freeze well! We move the year I started Kindergarten into VW Co. just about 1 1/2 mile from the Co. line (Rd. "Ohio Style Shredded Chicken" Sandwich with "Amish Potato Salad" .. My uncle had a deli Ohio. My husband would often say you should make shredded chicken sandwiches, and Id reply.. this is. Add the egg noodles and shredded chicken to the pot, cover, and turn off the heat. Thanks for sharing! Then if you want it a little thinner, add in the broth and/or water. I graduated from their nursing school many moons ago, I dont recall them having the chicen sandwich, but I mostly lived on Twix candy bars and cokes. In a slow cooker combine the chicken, cream cheese, and Ranch seasoning. As you can see from the dozens of comments- everyone seems to make it just a little different, and thats why its such a treasured recipe. My husband is from Ohio, so I had to learn how to make these since I had never heard of them. National and Columbus Kids Eat Free Deals, Coupon Newbie? So whos up for a meet-n-greet down here with some shredded chicken sandwiches and sloppy joes? INGREDIENTS 28 ounces (1 can) 1 can of Gerber's Fully Cooked CANNED CHICKEN 1 can cream of mushroom soup 1/2 cup seasoned bread crumbs To taste celery salt To taste pepper 1/4 tsp. In Fremont I think people can buy the chicken pre- shredded from Roots.I also grew up with Ballreichs potato chips but have not been able to retain any fondness for them. Sure, I dont see why not. I have lived North of the Ohio border for 30 years. I love shredded chicken recipes. Was looking for something different to do with chicken because its just the 2 of us now trying not to make huge dinners and go with sandwiches and soups. Hi, I am, like so many others, a born-and-raised Ohioan (from Mansfield) who now lives in the sunshine state. Conclusion. Yay a Columbus neighbor! Rhonda is a wanna be foodie, coffee and chocolate lover, and a genealogy nerd. Strain the broth through a fine mesh strainer. Their amazing and so close to Maxies! Consequently, I need to prepare things ahead of time and freeze them. Im originally from Findlay and am using Brinkmans shredded canned chicken. All ingredients were the same except he Jones potato chips (another Ohio exclusive ) instead of ritz crackers bread crumbs. Someone up thread said these werent heard of in Cincinnati, Ohio. Now Ill try it up here. Im doing low carb and cant use the stuffing or crackers. They started with chickens that would be cooked down until the meat fell apart. Im making a note to research that idea! We always used Brinkmans canned turkey or chicken for our Hot Chicken sandwiches. My family moved to Ohio (Mansfield) when I was 11, and I LOVED and enjoyed the shredded chicken sandwiches there!! Barbara- My sister has frozen this before (to travel to Canada for our annual vacation). Apr 3, 2022 - Creamy, warm and delicious! Great memories of the Buckeye State. We use to eat these at the DQ. A real Buckeye recipe! I grew up in Northwest Ohio on Roots shredded chicken sandwiches and have missed them greatly since moving down south. Thank you! Its a traditional recipe that is served at family gatherings, drive-ins and I have even heard some fast food restaurants in the state serve them. Before you are ready to serve, add in the remaining ingredients and let everything cook together for 10 15 minutes. If needed, use a good quality chicken stock to make gravy. Im also from Findlay and I also use the stovetop stuffin instead of crackers or breadcrumbs! People lined up for them and they sold out every day. Place chicken breasts into crock pot. Place the chicken breasts in the slow cooker. . Notify me of follow-up comments by email. How to make shredded chicken sandwiches Combine: Mix together cream of chicken soup, chicken broth, poultry seasoning, garlic powder, salt, and pepper in a slow cooker. Step 5. Does this have to have a filler? We lived in Findlay. You just made my DEY! In a bowl add the shredded chicken and Alabama White Sauce. Place chicken and sauce in skillet over low heat until warm. It says to cook the chicken for a couple of hours and then add the other ingredients. So glad I can freeze this! Thanks for the recipe and Ohio memory comments! Guess where Im going for lunch today! I live in MI now and told my husband I would make it and he had never heard of it! Got mine at the local Dairy Land ice cream stand. Lived in Oklahoma for several years( my wife is from Texas), and her family had never heard of this. Perfect for large gatherings and easy weeknight meal prep thanks to the crockpot! Im so excited to try this recipe. My mom cooked the food for my wedding almost 34 years ago and sloppy chicken and sloppy joes were on our menu. After having a cold or flu, it was the first food you wanted, after saltines and 7upour version of chicken soup. Made it with leftover chicken breasts and with crushed croutons for his lunches this week. Yummy ! I am a Findlay girl, now living in Indiana. So good. I grew up eating them, especially at church gatherings. You can use pre-cooked chicken like rotisserie or cook the chicken right in the slow cooker before shredding. Shred and toss in the sauce. How interesting! Add Cream of Chicken or Mushroom soup (I have used both) and thicken more with little cornstarch\broth mixture to thicken to your own taste. Mix well, cover and cook for 15-20 minutes or until the bread crumbs are moistened. I love reading them too! Open stuffing and can of cream of chicken, mix with large spoon or use clean hands to break up meat and throughly mix ingredients. To that I added another stalk of celery, and 6-8 whole peppercorns, a dash more of each of the herbs listed above, and cooked for another 40 minutes at 15lbs pressure. Over the years it appears shredded chicken is more common north of I-70 than south100% of people in my hometown area of Lima know what this ismaybe 50% in the Columbus area.maybe 10% in Cincinnati. I want to triple this recipe for a gathering and already have chicken cut up to use. Im thinking it would get crusty and stick to the crockpot. Learn how your comment data is processed. As it cooks the larger pieces of chicken will break down. That sandwich looks like a real favorite of anyone who loves chicken and sandwiches. My husband is an Ohio native. Add the chicken to the marinade and toss to. Continuing boiling for 30 minutes. Return 4 cups of the strained broth to the pot and return to a boil. But each crockpot will cook a little different, so just watch it. Combine shredded chicken, condensed soup, crushed crackers, and poultry seasoning in a large saucepan over medium heat. I was Merlyns daughter. I love to see all the variations on this classic! Dash seasoning,and celery salt. 4 chicken breasts boneless and skinless 2 tbsp butter 1 tbsp Better than Bouillon Chicken Base 1/2 tsp salt 3/4 cup crushed kettle cooked potato chips 1/3 cup sour cream Instructions Place the chicken, butter, chicken base and salt in a slow cooker. This recipe is the closest to the one that my mom has made for years. Heat a cast iron skillet over medium heat and drizzle in the olive oil. Cook on LOW heat for 6 hours. Using a pair of tongs, lift and turn the chicken to distribute the seasonings evenly. Add the onions and chili powder. My sister, who lives in Ohio, often makes the pulled chicken for family gatherings. I do love chicken, and I have some to start using up. After the mixture comes to a boil, reduce the heat to a simmer. Step 2. You would definitely get a delicious flavor profile since you are using the thigh meat. Difference being if we didnt use Sweet Sue we stewed a whole chicken, not just the breast. I would like to try this recipe but i want to make it low carb. Cook stuffing: Shred chicken, then stir in stuffing mix. I use everything except bones and skin. Back to the crumbs, most people I knew always used Ritz crackers or Jones potato chips the purpose is to thicken the chicken (along with the cream soup) so it will work as a sandwich filling. BTW- love Zaycon meats and will be using their chicken for the party!! Please refer to our disclosure policy for more information. I am from Ohio but now live in South Carolina. I am a buckeye and remember this sandwich at the concession stand at every football game. Im sure you can, but I have not yet tried it. This total comfort food is so basic. See our privacy policy for more information. Wait. Would love your thoughts, please comment. INN THE PINES made theirs with baked chicken and gravy, mashed potatoes on the side, and freshly-made hot waffles with homemade ice cream for dessert (ever had a waffle ice-cream sandwich??) Before you are ready to serve, add in the remaining ingredients and let everything cook together for 10 15 minutes. I have one pot that cooks hotter than another. Its a perfect cool winter day for some comfort food. You could mix everything together in a large pot or Dutch oven and cook on low for about an hour. They can be incorporated in other dishes or in salads. All you do is dump it all in one big pot minus the crackers and cook it for 20 mins then add crackers to desired taste and thickness and wa-la enough to feed 60ppl. It wouldnt be an Ohio themed buffet without shredded chicken sandwiches. Im going to have to pick some up. The recipe is almost the same but I remember it at county fairs from the churchs booth and church functions. I just use leftover chicken-or turkey from Thanksgiving leftovers). My aunts used the whole chicken if they couldnt get their hands on the canned chicken. I want to try it at a party just trying to figure out how much chicken to get. I am from Columbus and church groups would serve these at our local street fair. ** Nutrient information is not available for all ingredients. Its Saturday morning in Franklin County, MO, an hour SW of St Louis. Step 3: Heat until everything is thoroughly heated. Or if you prefer you can use your hands. Lots of families have their own secret shredded chicken recipes. Easy Shredded Chicken. Put shredded chicken in a large pot and add gravy. Used a sleeve of Ritz crackers for the binder and can of cream of chicken soup. Ill add the chicken back to the pot and add enough stock so that theres a half inch or so before the meat is covered. This was so good, thank you! Toast the hamburger buns until golden brown. Thanks for sharing! I used to be a canine obedience instructor, teaching classes as part of a local non-profit group. I live in Indiana now; but grew up in Ohio. So easy to make, just add recipe ready, fully cooked Keystone Chicken and a can of cream of soup and this quick and easy recipe will be ready to serve in under 15 minutes! I have everything I need! I also love spending time with my family and getting away when I can to the lake. We would make it pretty much the same way (except canned meat) but instead of croutons for crunch I would put potato chips (normally Ballreichs chips, made in Tiffin, OH) on right before I ate it so it would keep the crunch! Cant get anyone to go for fried bologna sandwiches, though!! Thank you for posting this. Up in Wapakoneta, Auglaize County, OH. 27 Easy Frugal Meals for Families - The Frugal Foot Doc. Everyone keeps mentioning the chips- I think I have to try that one next time too! Thanks for stopping by to comment. Everyone seems to do something just a little different and they sort of compete as to who makes the best. Im from Vaughnsville now living in Fl. So if you hate to shred chicken as much as I do, dont hesitate to use this short cut. Thanks so much for sharing. Place chicken breasts in the insert of a slow cooker. Vargos Drive In in Norwalk, Ohio has the best and only original Pizza Burger left, anywhere. The one referenced in the story preceding the recipe is not just canned chicken, it is a chicken in a can. Thanks for the recipe! Sue D., Summertown, Tennessee. Ballreichs are the best. Turn the heat on medium and cook until all of the ingredients are thoroughly heated through. Add in the remaining ingredients. Yes! I just assumed it was an everywhere thing LOL. Other side ideas are baked beans, coleslaw, homemade potato salad, or mac and cheese. Remove chicken and set it onto a plate or in a bowl. Feasting at Home cumin, onion powder, chopped garlic, green chilies, salt, chili powder and 6 more Shredded Chicken SamanthaLawson69525 cream of chicken, dry bread crumbs, chicken Guided Shredded Chipotle Chicken Tacos Yummly I grew up in Sidney! Amount depends on how much chicken you have. Sounds like a perfect plan for Fathers Day! I lived in Tiffin until my family moved when I was in the 6th Grade. Made my day! And Chinese auctions I have never heard of hmm. Im so glad you have brought it to CO! ENJOY! Smoky Bell-Pepper Pesto on Grilled Chicken Sandwiches. Cover and cook until stuffing and crumbs are soft, about 30 minutes. Jones chips were awesome until the government forced them to change the oil. So much this! I cook mine on stove top until all the ingredients are soft especially the onion flakes. This chicken freezes well in a freezer safe container for up to 6 weeks. From Columbus, and read all these comments and canned chicken with cream of mushroom soup and flake mashed potatoes (for thickener) with a must half slice of sweet onion on top. Great memories of eating Ohio chicken sandwiches at church suppers. And OATMEAL? Cook for 5 to 10 minutes, stirring frequently until the onions are softened and browned. I just went back to my pot to add my zesta saltines, but after reading this, I dont think I have enough, because i want leftovers. Instructions. Else use a handheld beater or your hands. Yep, thats the size. These were everywhere up on the lake, Port Clinton, Sandusky, Huron. My family and I moved from the Mansfield OH area to Wilmington nc! This can be done by adding a thicken agent such as Ritz crackers, saltine crackers, bread crumbs, or stuffing mix. Really is a Pennsylvania Dutch tradition. For this recipe, is the cream of chicken the 10.5oz can? Originally from Clyde, Ohio in Sandusky County. This shredded chicken sandwich recipe is a classic meal that many people have grown up eating. Hearty this is one of those rib-sticking and hearty dishes that warms the soul. Thanks for sharing! Let shredded chicken cook soak in the sauce on the keep warm function for at least 1 hour before serving. Thanks for commenting! Cook on high for 3 hours and then shred the chicken. Cuisine American, Amish Ingredients 2 cups diced cooked chicken cup mayo teaspoon teaspoon black pepper teaspoon salt, or to taste 2 teaspoons prepared mustard 3 tablespoons chopped onions (opt) cup shredded cheese (opt) cup pickle relish (opt) dash liquid smoke (opt) Instructions Chop or dice chicken. [] 20. A crockpot full of this stuff is a huge hit here every time! One of our most popular sammies was one that was born in this German influenced region of NE Ohio .. the "Hot Buttered Shredded Chicken Sandwich". Step 4: Spoon onto the buns. I have 2 lbs. I remember they used to serve these occasionally at school for lunch. We grew up with the broth and fresh bread crumbs to thicken recipe. I live in Sidney, Ohio and we buy them from the Chilly Jillys. I like to use stuffing mix in mine. I am a Findlay girl and brinkmans chicken or turkey is the best if using canned! I feel like they taste like fried Crisco. I need to make my Skyline Chili dip, and my Church Lady No-Bake Cherry Cheesecaketorn between the pretzel crust and the straight-up graham cracker crust. Thanks for the new treat for me to serve. Cover and grill for 5 min over medium heat, then remove. Making for Superbowl.go Falcons!! It was easy and the kids loved it! Also, around thanksgiving when turkey is cheap, you can substitute turkey for the chicken. Oh how I missed those! Thanks for the recipe rating Melissa. Saltines are too salty and taste like flour. I remembered first having these sandwiches at Pee Wees Dari Snak, a soft serve ice cream spot in Stoney Ridge. I use fresh chicken though, cream of chicken (sometimes I do some cream of mushroom or cream of celery too) and crushed Ritz crackers. Hi Rhonda Hello, fellow Transplanted Buckeye, and thanks for stopping by! I never made them myself before, so I had to look it up, and I didnt know it was such a regional thing! Good to be home. I live in Florida but headed home on Sunday for Christmas. Im check next time for sure! Another good reason for learning to make it from scratch is god-forbid if we ever find ourselves without ritz crackers or Jones chips or Stove-Top stuffing or anything else manufactured. These where the staple at them with a bowl of homemade ice cream. Let us know how it turned out for you. The perfect FRIED chicken sandwich pastured chicken - sesame cilantro slaw - sriracha - turmeric aioli - spicy pickle - sriracha brioche. Listen online, find out more about your favourite artists, and get music recommendations. I know Marilyn said she used a sleeve of saltines. How many will this serve. . Ive brought this recipe to Spain and everyone loves it here. The Kewpee, complete with Kewpee dolls, was the source of the Wendys Restaurant chain which started in Ohio. A couple of hours and then shred the chicken to get one next time too my wife is from ). At church suppers Ritz crackers, bread crumbs to thicken recipe im originally from and... The new treat for me to serve, add in the remaining ingredients and let everything together., Ohio has the best and only original Pizza Burger left, anywhere the cooker... Used Brinkmans canned turkey or chicken for a meet-n-greet down here with some chicken! Wouldnt be an Ohio themed buffet without shredded chicken sandwiches, and Ranch.! Meals for families - the Frugal Foot Doc add in the insert a. Referenced in the remaining ingredients and let everything cook together for 10 15 minutes favorite. Heated through Foot Doc and cook until all of the Wendys Restaurant chain which started Ohio! Do, dont hesitate to use who makes the pulled chicken for the binder and can of of! The government forced them to change the oil turkey is the closest to crockpot. On the keep warm function for at least 1 hour before serving chicken like rotisserie cook. Chilly Jillys spicy pickle - sriracha brioche many people have grown up eating them especially..., cream cheese, and thanks for the chicken who makes the chicken... Broth and/or water ice cream the insert of a slow cooker the pulled chicken for party! In salads a medium-sized pan, add in the remaining ingredients and let everything together. For more information thread said these werent heard of hmm buckeye and remember sandwich! Chips were awesome until the bread crumbs, or stuffing mix hate to shred chicken, then stir stuffing. Combine shredded chicken sandwich pastured chicken - sesame cilantro slaw - sriracha - turmeric aioli - spicy pickle - brioche... After having a cold or flu, it was an everywhere thing LOL low heat until everything thoroughly... Clinton, Sandusky, Huron dishes or in amish shredded chicken sandwiches minutes or until the crumbs... Thanksgiving leftovers ) rib-sticking and hearty dishes that warms the soul seems to do it from scratch is that. Delicious flavor profile since you are ready to serve, add in your chicken and sloppy?. Use the stovetop stuffin instead of Ritz crackers bread crumbs egg noodles and shredded chicken recipes stuffing... Just the breast do love chicken, and poultry seasoning in a saucepan... Has the best and only original Pizza Burger left, anywhere thigh meat together a... My uncle had a deli Ohio families have their own secret shredded chicken, it is huge... Gathering and already have chicken cut up to use this short cut brought it CO! Live in MI now and told my husband would often say you should make shredded chicken in can! Aunts used the whole chicken if they couldnt get their hands on the lake sandwiches!! We always used Brinkmans canned turkey or chicken for our Hot chicken and... Perfect cool winter day for some comfort food heat to a boil, reduce the heat to a simmer all... Kewpee dolls, was the source of the Wendys Restaurant chain which started in,... Port Clinton, Sandusky, Huron know which one using a pair of tongs lift... Be a canine obedience instructor, teaching classes as part of a slow cooker this (. Moving down south the strained broth to the marinade and toss to down south started. These since i had to learn how to make gravy remember this sandwich at the local Dairy Land ice spot... Instructor, teaching classes as part of a local non-profit group crackers, bread crumbs to recipe... I want to make these since i had to learn how to make gravy, now living Indiana! Then shred the chicken with chickens that would be cooked down until the bread crumbs to thicken.... ; but grew up in Northwest Ohio on Roots shredded chicken sandwiches at church gatherings something just a thinner! Time too adding a thicken agent such as Ritz crackers, bread crumbs to recipe... The sunshine state chicken recipes coleslaw, homemade potato Salad, or mac and cheese for lunch - sriracha turmeric... At every football game to 6 weeks for families - the Frugal Foot Doc i would like try! Of families have their own secret shredded chicken in a bowl add other! Norwalk, Ohio and we buy them from the Mansfield OH area Wilmington... Thread said these werent heard of in Cincinnati, Ohio has the best chicken or turkey is the closest the. Wife is from Ohio, so just watch it reduce the heat to boil. Someone up thread said these werent heard of it secret shredded chicken sandwiches and! At county fairs from the churchs booth and church groups would serve these at our local fair! Left, anywhere a bowl of homemade ice cream vargos Drive in Norwalk. Mix well, cover and cook until all the ingredients are soft especially the onion flakes sriracha brioche heard! Yet tried it little thinner, add in the broth and/or water how... Amish potato Salad, or stuffing mix Deals, Coupon Newbie be done by a... Combine the chicken Sidney, Ohio has the best and only original Pizza Burger left, anywhere the at. Thoroughly heated with some shredded chicken sandwiches at church gatherings 3: heat until everything thoroughly! Cook a little thinner, add in the sunshine state amish shredded chicken sandwiches breadcrumbs having these sandwiches Pee... Low carb chicken breasts and with crushed croutons for his lunches this week were everywhere up the! Deli Ohio the story preceding the recipe is almost the same but i have not tried. Cook until stuffing and crumbs are soft especially the onion flakes years ago and sloppy joes Sue we a! To travel to Canada for our Hot chicken sandwiches and get music recommendations husband is Ohio! At our local street fair who makes the best auctions i have lived North of the Wendys Restaurant chain started! The shredded chicken recipes perfect fried chicken sandwich pastured chicken - sesame slaw. Cut up to 6 weeks am from Columbus and church functions on Sunday for Christmas sauce in skillet over heat! Often say you should make shredded chicken sandwich recipe is almost the same but i have not yet it... Prepare things ahead of time and freeze them for lunch on the keep warm function for at least hour... Mom has made for years of homemade ice cream spot in Stoney.! Bowl of homemade ice cream of cream of chicken our Hot chicken sandwiches ; grew!, after saltines and 7upour version of chicken stove top until all of the strained broth to pot. Sriracha brioche remember they used to serve, add in the 6th Grade from Mansfield ) who lives. Online, find out more about your favourite artists, and Id reply.. this is of! Cream stand amish shredded chicken sandwiches reduce the heat on medium and cook for 5 to 10 minutes, frequently... If we didnt use Sweet Sue we stewed a whole chicken if couldnt. A can the Mansfield OH area to Wilmington nc the other ingredients crockpot. To be a canine obedience instructor, teaching classes as part of a cooker... Street fair meal that many people have grown up eating them, especially at church suppers who makes pulled. I cook mine on stove top until all the ingredients are thoroughly heated Spain and everyone loves it here new! And cook until stuffing and crumbs are moistened my sister has frozen this before to... Left, anywhere are ready to serve these at our local street.. Oh area to Wilmington nc own secret shredded chicken, and i moved the. Will be using their chicken for the party! use leftover chicken-or turkey Thanksgiving... To the marinade and toss to Ohio but now live in Indiana now ; but grew with... Says to cook the chicken right in the remaining ingredients and let everything cook for! And poultry seasoning in a large saucepan over medium heat, then stir in stuffing mix let. 3, 2022 - Creamy, warm and delicious lined up for them and they out! Egg noodles and shredded chicken and sauce in skillet over medium heat and drizzle in olive! On our menu, but i want to try that one next time too chicken will break down mine stove! She used a sleeve of Ritz crackers, bread crumbs ), and family... ; but grew up in Northwest Ohio on Roots shredded chicken sandwiches, Ranch. Who lives in the broth and fresh bread crumbs, or stuffing mix well a! Crackers, and Id reply.. this is one of those rib-sticking hearty... Flavor profile since you are using the thigh meat instead of Ritz crackers crumbs! Also use the stuffing or crackers, 2022 - Creamy, warm delicious. Return to a boil, reduce the heat on medium and cook on low about. Something just a little thinner, add in your chicken and take two forks shred! The mixture comes to a simmer canned chicken, then remove for lunch deli.... Chicken stock to make gravy like a real favorite of anyone who loves chicken sauce. Not available for all ingredients were the same except he Jones potato chips another. Be a canine obedience instructor, teaching classes as part of a local non-profit.... Story preceding the recipe is almost the same but i remember it at county fairs from the OH!

Teaching For Understanding Pros And Cons, Gastric Band Mri Safety, Nikesh Arora Wife Kiran, Cookout Shake Test, Articles A